Judging cocktail competitions is one of those jobs that sounds far more glamorous than it actually is ā long afternoons or evenings, a lot of sugar, and the quiet realisation that youāve agreed to taste far more drinks than any sensible adult should in one sitting. Still, the 2025 Singapore Finals of Woodford Reserveās The Wonderful Race a couple of months back reminded me why I keep saying yes.
The brief was deceptively simple: reinterpret the Old Fashioned. Which also happens to be my favourite cocktail, and one I use to judge any bar I visit. In reality, thatās like asking a tailor to redesign a classic suit without ruining the cut. Thereās nowhere to hide. Get the balance wrong and it sulks. Overdo the storytelling and the drink collapses under its own cleverness.
What impressed me this year was how many bartenders understood that the Old Fashioned isnāt about invention for its own sake ā itās about judgement. The eventual winner, Iām glad to report, was
@chavezmeljophn of
@barsomma , whose cocktail landed squarely in that sweet spot. His creation, Kingās Melon, sounded on paper like it might be an act of quiet rebellion ā hojicha-infused bourbon, melon, elderflower ā but in the glass it was disciplined, controlled, and still very much an Old Fashioned at heart. Sweetness reined in, structure intact, bourbon still doing the talking. Which, frankly, is harder than it looks.
Competitions like this are a useful reminder ā especially for those of us who write about drinks for a living ā that restraint is a skill, not a compromise. For me, the Old Fashioned remains the ultimate stress test because it doesnāt care for trends, theatrics, or Instagram garnish. It only demands that you understand proportion.
Also, for the record, judging alongside industry friends while trying to stay sharp after multiple rounds of tasting is a humbling exercise in self-awareness. I went home smelling strongly of alcohol, questioning my palate, and exceedingly grateful that I wasnāt the one behind the bar. Which is as it should be.
Letās have more of this in 2026.
#cocktails #cocktaillover