Why Russian?
text by Manca Arnuš
@ma__rnus and Ana Muñoz
@ana_mm10
Ana from Cádiz and Manca from Ljubljana studied Russian Philology in Tartu and spent a summer in Almaty. They are critically reflecting on their time in both spaces, and the many questions that arise when knowledge is narrowly shaped by the dominant national narratives and colonial policies.
“But why Russian?”, everyone keeps asking me. I never seem to give a satisfactory reply, each time blatantly expected by that one person who knows better than studying a language of the well-known oppressor.
And what happens when two women, eager to uncover what Russian academia prefers not to say, meet in Barlova, drink beer, dream of reading modern literature instead of Tolstoy, long to learn accents and dialects rather than memorize Grammar and Syntax, begin asking why Tatarstan, Dagestan, or Kazan never appeared in our syllabi, and wonder what would happen if Russian Philology was instead called Russophone Philology?
I am so intrigued by the mechanisms of the so-called “big languages”. This notion is not solely based on the number of speakers or translations made annually into a certain language, but rather on the language’s dominance which inseparably entails cultural and historical primacy. This ever so obvious yet often invisible veil of influence has always fascinated me—for example, at one point during WWII Slovenia was occupied by all its four neighbours, then Nazi Austria, Independent State of Croatia, Kingdom of Hungary, and fascist Kingdom of Italy. Naturally, Slovenian was prohibited, names and surnames were changed to sound more German, Italian, Hungarian and Croatian. But the power of the neighbouring languages, German still being the strongest.
Criticizing the self-indulgence of the Western languages as the first thing, imported by the conqueror, Glissant emphasizes the concept of relation and errantry as essentially undermining the monolingualism of the conquest. It is only in acknowledging this errantry, this “peripheral” thought, that both parties are allowed to exist in relation
text on
@syg.ma.editorial
design by Rok Ifko Krajnc rok___ik
photos by Ana Muñoz & León Ihrke